Thomas Gibson
19 Jun 2024 · Coroner Chris Morris · Manchester South
This report repeats 1 earlier warning. See the linked reports.
The coroner's concerns
1. misinterpretation of ECG results leading to missed diagnosis
“a narrow focus on the error of three different doctors to interpret two ECGs correctly (rather than any broader consideration of the context in which such misinterpretations occurred) represents a missed opportunity to fully understand the factors that led to Mr [name redacted] discharge from hospital, thus creating a risk of future deaths”
2. lack of communication guidance across specialties and roles
“there does not appear to be clear guidance available to those working within the Trust as to what is required when communicating (particularly as to test results and a patient's presentation) as between different specialisms and as between different roles within the team”
3. inadequate contextual information for test review
“there is no specific guidance as to expected minimum standards as to obtaining appropriate context / information for clinicians (whether from the HIVE system or otherwise) when asked to review a single test or investigation result in isolation”
4. missing senior review for incongruous test results
“there does not currently appear to be any particular requirement in place for a senior review of the patient to take place in circumstances where diagnostic tests undertaken yield results which appear incongruous / unexpected in the context of their presentation”
5. absence of ECG audit before discharge
“no wider audit of ECGs interpreted in the Emergency Department / Acute Medical Unit prior to discharge of patients appears to have been undertaken”
6. insufficient discharge summary audit
“no audit as to the sufficiency of detail contained in discharge summaries appears to have been undertaken to date in the light of the issues identified by the Trust's High Impact Learning Assessment”
Linked reports
Closely relatedConfidence 0.90 · high
Earlier report
“Communication between speciality consultants ~ lack of any system to ensure that communication occurs between the treating consultants as to the necessity for identifying and documenting any potential ongoing risks”
This report
“there does not appear to be clear guidance available to those working within the Trust as to what is required when communicating (particularly as to test results and a patient's presentation) as between different specialisms and as between different roles within the team.”
Responses
2024-0327-Responses-from-NICE-and-MFT.pdf ↗· National Institution for Health and Care Excellence
Stated action · 2024-08-08
“we have focused on the Human Factors of errors in clinical medicine and have engaged with our Human Factors Academy (HFA). This will support us to understand better the other factors at play which contribute to incorrect ECG interpretation; and which can be mitigated in the future. 1”